The answer to this question is complex and open to interpretation. Cole's feelings for Alison are never explicitly stated in the show, but we can infer them through his actions and interactions with her.
Here are some key points to consider:
- Cole's initial attraction: Cole was initially attracted to Alison, and they shared a few intimate moments.
- Cole's feelings for Spencer: Cole eventually develops feelings for Spencer, Alison's twin sister. This suggests he might not have been as deeply invested in Alison as he initially appeared.
- Alison's manipulative nature: Alison is known for manipulating people, and Cole could have been one of her victims.
- Cole's protective instincts: Despite his conflicted feelings, Cole often acts protectively towards Alison, especially in the early seasons.
Ultimately, whether Cole truly loved Alison remains ambiguous. His actions and feelings towards her were complex and driven by a combination of attraction, confusion, and perhaps even a sense of obligation due to Alison's manipulative nature.
