The answer to this question depends entirely on individual preferences and what scares you the most. However, some of the most commonly cited as the scariest in the Conjuring franchise include:
The Conjuring (2013):
- The Perron Family's Story: The film's basis in the real-life Perron family's haunted farmhouse experience adds an extra layer of unsettling realism.
- Bathsheba Sherman: The film's main antagonist, Bathsheba Sherman, is a terrifying and powerful entity with a tragic backstory.
- Jump Scares: The film utilizes jump scares effectively, creating moments of genuine terror.
The Conjuring 2 (2016):
- The Enfield Poltergeist: The film's inspiration from the infamous Enfield Poltergeist case in England adds to its unsettling atmosphere.
- Valak: The demonic nun, Valak, is a visually striking and terrifying character with a haunting presence.
- The Crooked Man: The film features a creepy and unsettling children's rhyme about the Crooked Man, which adds to the overall sense of dread.
Annabelle (2014):
- The Doll's Origin Story: The film explores the origin story of the infamous Annabelle doll, adding depth and backstory to the character.
- The Doll's Malevolence: Annabelle's malevolent nature is effectively portrayed, creating a feeling of unease and dread.
- The Doll's Appearance: The doll's realistic appearance and unsettling demeanor contribute to its terrifying nature.
Ultimately, the scariest Conjuring film is the one that resonates most strongly with your personal fears and preferences.